We scored the same 2,000 birth charts under 12 readings of pitra dosh. The share of charts with it ran from 0.5% to 67.8%. The planets never changed. Only the rule did.

Pitra dosh is a chart pattern that tradition links to the family line. Every reading we found looks at the 9th house, the Sun or both. The 9th house is the part of the chart for father, elders and ancestors.

Our API uses rule DO-04. The dosha is present when any one of six things is true. The Sun, Rahu or Ketu sits in the 9th house. Rahu or Ketu sits in the same sign as the ruler of the 9th house. Or that ruler sits in house 6, 8 or 12. Under this rule, 53.9% of our 2,000 births had pitra dosh.

Other readings give other counts. The Sun in the same sign as Rahu flagged 8.3% of the same births. The Sun with Rahu inside the 9th house flagged 0.5%. A long checklist that adds Saturn flagged 67.8%.

So a bare "yes" tells your users little. The useful part of the answer is the cause. Our API names the cause of each trigger it finds.

The readings other sources use

Pitra dosh has no single classical rule. One detailed guide we read lists five competing definitions. It also says the term is not used in the oldest texts the way apps use it today. Our glossary entry says the same in short: rules differ between schools.

Here are the main readings we found, in plain words. Rahu and Ketu are the two points where the Moon's path crosses the Sun's path. "With" means in the same sign.

Reading

Where we saw it

The Sun with Rahu, in any house

Called the most cited definition by one guide

The Sun with Rahu, only in the 9th house

The stricter version, in the same guide

The Sun sharing a sign with Saturn, Rahu or Ketu

A calculator's list of main signs

Saturn, Rahu or Ketu placed in house 9

The same calculator

The 9th ruler sharing a sign with Saturn, Rahu or Ketu

The same calculator

The 9th ruler in house 6, 8 or 12

The guide and the calculator

The Sun joined or aspected by Rahu or Ketu

One learning page

An aspect, or drishti, is a planet's "look" at another sign. Some sources need one item from the list. Others need two at once, such as a touched Sun and a touched 9th house. The API's rule is closest to the calculator's 9th house items, without Saturn. It adds the Sun in the 9th house, and one cause is enough.

How our API checks pitra dosh in a kundli

Every house here is a whole sign house. The rising sign is house 1, the next sign is house 2, and so on. The ruler of a house is the planet that rules its sign. Rahu and Ketu rule no sign, under rule CH-01.

Houses 6, 8 and 12 are the dusthanas, the houses tradition calls difficult. "With" means the same sign, however far apart in degrees. Rule GAP-07 says so.

The check fits in a few lines. This sketch follows the same steps as the API.

// Pitra dosh check, as in rule DO-04.
// house: each planet's house (1 to 12). sign: each planet's sign. ninthLord: ruler of house 9.
function pitraCheck(house, sign, ninthLord) {
  const causes = [];
  for (const planet of ["Sun", "Rahu", "Ketu"]) {
    if (house[planet] === 9) {
      causes.push(`${planet.toLowerCase()}-in-9th`);
    }
  }
  for (const node of ["Rahu", "Ketu"]) {
    if (sign[node] === sign[ninthLord]) {
      causes.push(`${node.toLowerCase()}-with-9th-lord`);
    }
  }
  if ([6, 8, 12].includes(house[ninthLord])) {
    causes.push("ninth-lord-in-dusthana");
  }
  return { present: causes.length > 0, causes };
}

The six cause names in that sketch are the same values the API returns. Each trigger in the response carries a cause, the planet, a short how sentence and the house. You can key your own text on cause without reading the sentence.

A worked example: John Doe

John Doe was born on Aug 15, 1990, at 10:30 AM in New York. His rising sign is Virgo. Count nine signs from Virgo and you reach Taurus, so Taurus is his 9th house. Venus rules Taurus, so Venus is his 9th ruler.

Planet

Sign

House

Sun

Cancer

11

Venus (9th ruler)

Cancer

11

Ketu

Cancer

11

Jupiter

Cancer

11

Rahu

Capricorn

5

Saturn

Sagittarius

4

Moon

Taurus

9

The Moon sits in his 9th house, but the Sun, Rahu and Ketu do not. Venus is in house 11, not 6, 8 or 12. But Ketu shares Cancer with Venus. That is one cause, so the API says the dosha is present. This is its answer, shortened. John Doe, born Aug 15, 1990, at 10:30 AM in New York:

{
  "dosha": "pitra",
  "present": true,
  "ninth_lord": "Venus",
  "triggers": [
    {
      "graha": "Ketu",
      "how": "conjunct the 9th lord (Venus)",
      "cause": "ketu-with-9th-lord",
      "house": 11
    }
  ],
  "houses": [11],
  "answer": {
    "status": "present",
    "headline": "Pitra dosha is present, because Ketu sits with the ruler of your 9th house."
  }
}

The call is POST /v1/dosha/pitra with the birth date, time and place. POST /v1/dosha/all runs it with the other doshas in one call. The full response also states the rule it tested, word for word. The field list is in the API reference.

John's result also depends on the reading. His Sun sits with Ketu, so a "Sun with Rahu or Ketu" reading says yes. His Sun is not with Rahu, so the most cited reading says no.

2,000 births, 12 readings

We picked 2,000 random birth moments between 1950 and 2009. Each one was in New York, Chicago, Houston or Los Angeles. For each birth, we called the API's pitra check with the true node and the mean node. We also fetched every planet's sign and house. Then we scored each birth under every reading below.

Reading

Births with it

Share

The Sun with Rahu in the 9th house

10

0.5%

The Sun with Rahu, any house

167

8.3%

The Sun with Saturn

176

8.8%

The Sun sharing a sign with Saturn, Rahu or Ketu, plus a touched 9th house

312

15.6%

The Sun with Rahu or Ketu

355

17.8%

The Sun sharing a sign with Saturn, Rahu or Ketu

501

25.1%

The 9th ruler in house 6, 8 or 12, alone

511

25.6%

The Sun joined or aspected by Rahu or Ketu

1,033

51.6%

Our API, rule DO-04, true node

1,077

53.9%

Our API's rule, mean node

1,081

54.0%

Our API's rule, plus Saturn in the 9th or with the 9th ruler

1,246

62.3%

The long checklist: any Sun or 9th house item above

1,357

67.8%

Bar chart of 2,000 random births scored under 12 readings of pitra dosh, from 0.5% for the Sun with Rahu in the 9th house to 67.8% for a long checklist, with the API's rule at 53.9%

For the aspect row, we used the aspects our API gives Rahu and Ketu, under rule AS-05. Each one looks at the 5th, 7th and 9th sign from itself. A "touched" 9th house means Saturn, Rahu or Ketu in house 9 or beside its ruler. It also counts the ruler in house 6, 8 or 12.

Two outside estimates match our counts. One guide's estimate for the Sun with Rahu is 8% to 10%. We counted 8.3%. Its estimate for the 9th ruler in house 6, 8 or 12 is about a quarter. We counted 25.6%.

The learning page that adds aspects puts its reading near 20%. Our count for the Sun with Rahu or Ketu, 17.8%, is close to that. Adding the 5th and 9th sign aspects lifts it to 51.6%. Another page says about 10 to 15% of charts, with a list of several patterns behind the number.

Why the API's rule flags half of all charts

One cause does most of the work. Houses 6, 8 and 12 are 3 of the 12 houses. The 9th ruler sat in one of them in 511 births. Each of the other five causes covered 158 to 203 births.

Cause in the response

Births

Share of all 2,000

ninth-lord-in-dusthana

511

25.6%

ketu-with-9th-lord

203

10.2%

ketu-in-9th

173

8.7%

rahu-in-9th

164

8.2%

rahu-with-9th-lord

160

8.0%

sun-in-9th

158

7.9%

Most charts with the dosha had one cause only: 802 of the 1,077. Another 258 had two causes, and 17 had three. In 317 charts, the 9th ruler in house 6, 8 or 12 was the only cause.

The API's rule and the Sun-with-Rahu reading also pick different people. Take the 167 births with the Sun and Rahu together. The API said yes to 86 and no to 81. The API said yes to 991 births where the Sun and Rahu sit apart. The two rules test different placements.

This is why your screen should lead with the cause, not the yes. "Ketu sits with the ruler of your 9th house" is a fact a user can check. "You have pitra dosh" alone is not.

The birth time changes the answer

The 9th house is counted from the rising sign, and the rising sign changes about every two hours. So the answer needs an accurate birth time. The Sun-with-Rahu reading uses only two signs, so the date is usually enough.

We checked John's birth day every 10 minutes, from 12:00 AM to 11:50 PM in New York. That is 144 checks with the same date and place.

Birth time on Aug 15, 1990

9th ruler

Answer

Cause

12:00 AM to 1:20 AM

Saturn

Yes

rahu-in-9th, ninth-lord-in-dusthana

1:30 AM to 3:40 AM

Saturn

No

none

3:50 AM to 6:10 AM

Jupiter

Yes

ketu-with-9th-lord

6:20 AM to 8:40 AM

Mars

No

none

8:50 AM to 11:20 AM

Venus

Yes

ketu-with-9th-lord

11:30 AM to 1:50 PM

Mercury

No

none

2:00 PM to 4:10 PM

Moon

Yes

sun-in-9th, ketu-in-9th

4:20 PM to 6:20 PM

Sun

Yes

ketu-with-9th-lord, ninth-lord-in-dusthana

6:30 PM to 7:50 PM

Mercury

Yes

ninth-lord-in-dusthana

8:00 PM to 9:00 PM

Venus

Yes

ketu-with-9th-lord, ninth-lord-in-dusthana

9:10 PM to 10:10 PM

Mars

No

none

10:20 PM to 11:30 PM

Jupiter

Yes

ketu-with-9th-lord

11:40 PM to 11:50 PM

Saturn

Yes

rahu-in-9th, ninth-lord-in-dusthana

The answer was yes on 93 of the 144 checks. It flipped between yes and no 8 times in one day. John's real time, 10:30 AM, sits inside the 8:50 AM to 11:20 AM stretch.

If your form lets users skip the birth time, do not show a pitra dosh answer. Our free kundli tool shows the rising sign and every house for a given time. You can see the shift yourself.

Banner inviting readers to open the free kundli tool and see the 9th house and its ruler for any birth time

The node setting barely matters

Rahu can be calculated two ways. The true node is its real position, and the mean node is a smoothed average. Our glossary explains both. The API uses the true node unless you send node: "mean".

Only 30 of our 2,000 births changed their answer between the two. The mean node gave 1,081 yes answers against 1,077. For this check, the choice of node is a small setting.

What to show your users

Lead with the cause. Show the trigger's how sentence or your own text keyed on cause. Then show the 9th ruler and its house, so users can follow the logic.

Name the rule. The response carries the rule it tested. Show it, and say that other astrologers use other rules. That one line gives users the reason two apps can differ.

Keep the tone calm. The API's own answer calls a dosha "a tendency to keep in mind, not a fixed fate". Its meaning text reads pitra dosh as a duty to honor your family line. Keep your own text in that spirit. Remedies appear in the reading sections only when the chart has the dosha, under rule RM-04.

Our doshas feature page shows the full response for each dosha. The kaal sarp check has its own setting gaps, covered in how the kaal sarp dosh check works. The manglik check lists exceptions without applying them, as our manglik post shows.

Banner for the yogas and doshas API page, which shows each dosha check with the cause and rule it used

Across our 2,000 births, the 12 readings never disagreed about where a planet was. They disagreed about which placements count. Show the cause, and tell your users which rule you picked.